Are You a Human? (newyorker.com)
¶Are you a robot? If you’re not, you’re going to be pretty sure you’re not. Still, online at least, you likely find it difficult to tell who else is and is not. Businesses find this difficult, too, and it’s getting harder all the time. If you were forced to guess, the odds would tell you to guess robot, because at this point there are more bots online than people. To deal with this problem, businesses retain bot-detection and bot-management firms, a specialty within the field of cybersecurity. Their task used to be to block bots, but, with the rise of agentic A.I., that has changed. Now the problem is how to let in the good bots (like the avatar you send to the Gap to buy you a new pair of pants) and keep out the bad bots (like the thief trying to scrape the data of every Gap customer). The rest of us have to be our own bot detectors.
¶Bot detection used to be literally that. Detect bots. If bot, block.
¶AI has changed the detection game, though. More specifically, the rise of agentic AI is forcing the game to change, and that is literally just getting underway. Today’s bot detection has a new layer — determining the type of bot. If bot, determine type, block if bad.
¶We humans aren’t being pushed out of the internet yet, but we’re certainly losing its attention.
¶BTW, I have no idea how The New Yorker missed an opportunity to include a reference to its prophetic 1993 “On the Internet, nobody knows you’re a dog” cartoon. The omission of this obvious tieback is a pretty good indicator that AI wasn’t involved in writing the article, though. So there’s that.